Shane Monks represented the Applicant, instructed by De Vere Lawyers.
The Applicant leased premises in the Riverside Centre, Brisbane, from the Respondent. A clause of the lease allowed the lessor to serve notice reviewing the base rent to market “at any time in the period commencing three (3) months before a Market Review Date and expiring on the next Market Review Date”. In October 2008, the Respondent served notice reviewing the rent as at the 1 July 2008 Market Review Date. The Applicant contended that the notice was out of time, as the period for giving it had expired on 1 July 2008.
The principal issue was whether “the next Market Review Date” meant the subject review date or the one following it. The Court held it meant the following date. The clause’s reference to there being no “following Market Review Date” would otherwise be superfluous, and the same expression clearly carried that meaning elsewhere in the lease. Although the construction allowed the lessor considerable time to give notice, it was not so absurd or inconsistent with the parties’ commercial purposes as to displace the ordinary meaning of the words. The arguments in favour of the Respondent’s construction were sufficiently powerful not to be overcome by the contra proferentem rule, even if it applied. The notice was therefore valid.
The application was dismissed with costs.
The judgment can be read by clicking here
