Shane Monks appeared on behalf of the second respondent, instructed by Clyde & Co.
This appeal arose from a dispute in which the appellant alleged that the respondents engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct during the sale of a shopping centre by representing that certain tenants were not in arrears and had no relevant history of rental arrears, thereby causing the appellant to pay more than the property’s true value. At first instance, the proceedings were dismissed because the appellant failed to prove that the respondents had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, that it had relied on that conduct, or that it had suffered any loss.
The Full Court allowed the appeal and held that the respondents had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and that the appellant had suffered loss as a result of relying on that conduct. In reaching that conclusion, the Court held that, taken together, the respondents’ conduct conveyed that the tenants were not in arrears and had no history of arrears, when that was not in fact the case. The appellant relied on those representations because, had the true position been known, it would have been prepared to offer a lower amount for the shopping centre, with the result that the purchase would not have proceeded. Accordingly, the Court held that the trial judge erred by focusing too narrowly on individual reports and by overstating the appellant’s ability and obligation to discover the true position through further inquiry. On the question of damages, the Court determined that the centre’s true value at the time of acquisition was approximately $51.65 million, rather than the $55.25 million paid, resulting in a recoverable loss to the appellant.
The judgment can be read by clicking here
