Shane Monks represented the Applicant, instructed by Hynes Legal.
The Applicant body corporate sought review of a decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission not to direct the Second Respondent contractor to rectify allegedly defective building work, more specifically, the aluminium composite panel (ACP) sunshades affixed to the Meriton tower in Brisbane. The Applicant contended that the ACPs constituted an undue risk of fire spread via the façade, contrary to Requirement 2.4(a)(iii) of Specification C1.1 of the 2009 Building Code of Australia.
While the ACPs were found to be combustible, the risk of fire spread was held not to be undue, applying a multifactorial evaluative assessment. Had a direction been warranted, it would not have been unfair to give one. Neither rectification costs, the asserted prejudice to the builder, nor prevailing industry practice at the time of construction constituted relevant unfairness.
The Commission’s decision was confirmed. Directions were made for any costs submissions.
The judgment can be read by clicking here
