Shane Monks represented the Appellant, instructed by Alexander Law.
The Appellant, which had guaranteed a company’s obligations to the Respondent under a contract, appealed a decision refusing it leave to make substantial amendments to its statement of claim shortly before the trial of a commercial cause. The proposed amendments denied liability on the basis that the Respondent’s claims for payment did not comply with the contract. They also alleged an obligation to provide compliant invoices before demanding payment under the guarantee, and that the principal debtor was entitled to repayment of more than USD 18 million.
Fraser JA (Philippides JA and Douglas J agreeing) upheld the primary judge’s refusal. The non-compliance pleas merely repeated the contract’s terms without identifying the documents said to be missing. No authority supported the alleged obligation to provide compliant invoices before demand, particularly where the guarantee preserved the debtor’s claims and defences. The repayment claim was also deficient. It rolled up distinct statutory and contractual claims, attributed the same remedy to each, and did not plead the facts needed to establish causation.
The appeal was dismissed with costs, as was the Appellant’s application for a stay.
The judgment can be read by clicking here
